Humberstone Bank Farm – beyond nature

IMG_7018 - Copy

Yorkshire Water is making an interesting offer – help them improve water quality, water retention and carbon storage on their land while ‘working with the sporting interest’ on an upland farm north of Blubberhouses.

Blubberhouses Moor in Yorkshire is mentioned in Inglorious (page 59) as the site where a stroppy rich man, Lord Walsingham, shot 1070 Red Grouse on his own (well, he was the only shooter, he had three Purdeys, two loaders and 40 beaters with him). It is said that he was piqued that royalty had turned down a day’s grouse shooting at his moor (perhaps because there weren’t enough grouse to shoot), so he started at about 5am and finished a little before 7pm and killed 1070 Red Grouse in a day – just to prove a point. That’s no doubt why the road sign says ‘Please drive carefully’. The history and present of driven grouse shooting is punctuated with similar pointless days of mass wildlife-killing, often to make men feel better about themselves.

But back to Humberstone Bank Farm, (which is only near Blubberhouses). Yorkshire Water’s agricultural tenants are retiring and so the water company is taking the land back in-hand, although the shooting rights are owned separately¹ (see Inglorious pages 68-69 for a quick, but I hope informative, gallop through this matter).

This looks a very promising move to maximise the benefits of the site to society and to the company. These benefits would include water quality, carbon storage and biodiversity. A large part of the site (around two thirds) is an SSSI which has been in poor condition but is now (possibly, I don’t know, because there is a management plan in place) in ‘Unfavourable recovering’ condition. The documentation states that Sphagnum recovery and restoration of the peatbogs is an aim of the future of this site.

Yorkshire Water has the following aims:

maximising the following outcomes:

• improved water quality
• carbon storage and capture
• improved biodiversity
• slowed water run-off
• wildfire mitigation
• driven grouse shooting
• economic stock grazing
Can you spot the odd one out?
If we were to put these in priority order, for a water company land owner, we might order them as follows:
  1. improved water quality
  2. slowed water run-off
  3. carbon storage and capture
  4. improved biodiversity
  5. economic stock grazing
  6. wildfire mitigation
  7. driven grouse shooting
I have no idea what the current arrangements for driven grouse shooting are on this site, and Yorkshire Water may be constrained by their relationship with the owners of the shooting rights, but we know that high intensity land management for driven grouse shooting is inimicable to several of the other aims.
A public company really doesn’t have any business to be encouraging a rich person’s sport – it’s hardly a societal benefit. Driven grouse shooting benefits the few at the expense of the many (see all 304 pages of Inglorious). We know that intensive management for driven grouse shooting as a hobby, leads to increased flood risk, reductions in water quality, reduced aquatic biodiversity and increased carbon emissions – those are big societal issues, experienced, sometimes unknowingly, by us all. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
But this is a good step forward by Yorkshire Water and they are to be congratulated on what they seem to be edging towards. We should all, all of us, email Yorkshire Water at [email protected] to congratulate them on this move. My email suggests that they should get out of driven grouse shooting as quickly as possible on all their land.  If you are a shareholder or customer then I’m sure they will be even more thrilled to get your feedback on this initiative.
And another thing you could do, if you thought it a good idea, would be to ask people to sign this NEW e-petition asking the Westminster government to debate a ban on driven grouse shooting for all the reasons above and many more too. We’ve already passed 4000 signatures and that’s inside the first 24 hours.
 ———————————————————————————————————————-
 1. I’m grateful to Yorkshire Water for clarifying that the shooting rights are owned separately
[registration_form]

3 Replies to “Humberstone Bank Farm – beyond nature”

Comments are closed.