A Damascene conversion?

A road in Damascus Photo: Dimashq206 via wikimedia commons
A road in Damascus Photo: Dimashq206 via wikimedia commons

It’s quite funny how the shooting community is falling over itself in its bid to express its love for the Hen Harrier these days. Anyone mentioning the phrase ‘rats wi’ wings’ is shushed severely.

Photo: Tim Melling
Photo: Tim Melling

One of the more striking and welcome expressions of love for the Hen Harrier (a strong candidate for the shortlist for Britain’s national bird) was Mark Osborne who is a well known name in the shooting community.  I believe he may have been an enthusiastic funder of the GWCT for several years and he is clearly a keen grouse shooter himself as exemplified by his articles on driven grouse shooting (356 birds in Speyside on 12 August)  and walked-up shooting (31 birds in Derbyshire a few days later).

Given that Mr Osborne has been incredibly unlucky to be managing land near where birds of prey have been found illegally killed it is good that he has joined in the love-fest for the Hen Harrier and has written his praise for the bird on  the William Powell website.

Failure ‘is not an option‘, apparently for Mark Osborne when he takes on an under-performing moor like Glenogil, in the Angus Glens.  Under-performing for Red Grouse bags that is. Road-building, fencing, hare-shooting, anti-tick chemicals, and unrelenting legal predator control seem to be the measures that turn an under-performing moor into one where 800 Red Grouse can be shot in three days shooting. Glenogil was bought in 2004 by the ‘wizard financier’ John Dodd who used Mark Osborne as his advisor but it wasn’t all plain sailing for Mr Dodd.

Hen-Harrier-Day-300pxI wonder how many Hen Harriers Mr Osborne has on the land he manages for Red Grouse?  And how many he would like to have? When moor managers like Mark Osborne, for whom failure is not an option, say they want Hen Harriers everywhere then their recovery cannot be far away.  It is men just like Mr Osborne on whom the future of the Hen Harrier depends.

In the Farmers Weekly Mr Osborne was once quoted as saying ”We in the countryside are going to have to accept often significant damage caused by raptors, but equally if this damage is at a level that threatens to wipe out the prey species, or even take their populations to a vulnerable low, then we should be unequivocally pushing for control of raptors in some format. That way we may actually make some progress.‘.

I hadn’t realised that the road to Damascus went through a grouse moor in Scotland.

Likes(69)Dislikes(9)
Website Pin Facebook Twitter Myspace Friendfeed Technorati del.icio.us Digg Google StumbleUpon Premium Responsive

Get email notifications of new blog posts

Registration confirmation will be emailed to you.


6 Replies to “A Damascene conversion?”

  1. Lots of new roads seem to be appearing through grouse moors in Scotland these days- whether any go to Damascus is another matter

    Likes(21)Dislikes(1)
  2. The National Trust obviously don't have any concern over Mr Osborne's stance on raptors - he's one of their High Peak estate shooting tenants, only a short harrier flight away from the location of the Derbyshire Hen Harrier day venue. http://www.moorlandassociation.org/newsshow.asp?art=68

    I wonder how many harrier's, goshawks and peregrines are on the land he rents from them?

    How is the National Trust's vision for their Peak district estate going, its gone fairly quiet so Im assuming they are implementing sweeping changes to make it a truly sustainable upland landscape?

    Likes(13)Dislikes(1)
  3. Doesn't fill one with hope does it? I suppose this guy is one end of the spectrum though. Most are not, most actually live in the city and are presently a combination of disinterested and confused. That suits the grouse lobby as it will not lead to change. Birders/naturalists/farmers of the old school persuasion/anti-corruption advocates have to persuade those in the middle that they are right to feel short changed,duped and mislead. This battle will be a test of resolve though. Landowners, gamekeepers and the shooters themselves have had to do nothing to get their own way for a long time and many are loath to give an inch

    Likes(12)Dislikes(0)
  4. When I read this about Mr Osborne the other day I'm glad I was sitting down. You could have knocked me down with a feather. Shall we say he has a certain reputation in the uplands [Note: short phrase removed by Mark, perhaps overcautiouly]. As you say Mark it is people such as these that hold the future of the Hen Harrier in their hands and for that matter Peregrine and Short-eared Owl as well, lets hope the conversion is genuine. However I'll not be holding my breath as the whiff of hypocrisy is strong on the grouse moors at the moment .

    Likes(15)Dislikes(1)
  5. This man has a history. [***************************************]. He was once managing next to the RSPB reserve at Geltsdale. Did we see Hen Harriers being successful at that time? No. His love for Short eared Owls is well known in these parts!!

    Likes(1)Dislikes(0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.