Raking over some embers

I’ve been reading scientific papers about burning heather recently. They are a bit heavy going and there seems to be quite a lot of acrimony in this field of learned research – which does, in some ways, make it all the more interesting.

I went back, almost four years, and re-read what I wrote about the GWCT’s and YFTB’s shocking behaviour over #burningbloggate. See these blogs in this order; first, second, third, fourth, fifth.

The paper that was leaked, and published whilst still under embargo, was this one – click here.

The paper in question is long and frankly, a bit dull in places, but my interest perked up (back in March 2016) when I saw that this blog was referenced in the paper. In a sentence that said ‘Individuals closely associated with the RSPB have made unambiguous calls for burning to be banned [137]‘ the reference cited was none other than a post on this blog, this one: Avery M. 2014 Burn, maybe burn (aka Wuthering Moors 40). See https://markavery.info/2014/03/07/burn-burn/. Fame indeed! And I know I am large of stature, but I am only an individual not individuals, so the paper first falls down on being able to count. Second, I think it falls down on the ‘closely associated with the RSPB‘ unless it is suggesting that I am an RSPB member, which I am, but then there are over a million of us. Maybe it means that I used to work for the RSPB – I did – although that was five years in the past when this paper emerged into the murk through the auspices of GWCT and YFTB. But the third error, in a single sentence, is that these individuals (ie I) ‘have made unambiguous calls for burning to be banned‘ in that blog post. Well, you have a look at that post and help me to find where it says, unambiguously that I think that all burning should be banned – click here. I don’t.

It’s always a good idea if those moaning about politicising debates don’t miscount, misrepresent or misconstrue others, otherwise it looks like they are politicising the debate.

But I can’t say I’m all that bothered – after all it has taken me nearly four years to correct these errors.

But there are other burning arguments too.

Website Pin Facebook Twitter Myspace Friendfeed Technorati del.icio.us Digg Google StumbleUpon Premium Responsive

Get email notifications of new blog posts

Registration confirmation will be emailed to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.