FoI Friday – 1

Dear Peak District National Park

This is a request under the Freedom of Information regulations, but in any case you should be happy to answer it.

Please answer the following:

  1. Did the PDNP contact The Times newspaper by email, letter or telephone concerning Simon Barnes’s articles about raptor persecution in the Peak District?  I ask, because it has been suggested to me that you might have done. A rapid straight ‘no’ would suffice if that is the answer.
  2. If the answer to question 1 is ‘yes’, please send me details of what you wrote or said and any replies that you received.
  3. Are you aware (perhaps through being copied in) of any other representations made by others on this subject? I’m not sure this falls under FoI – you had better check – but I’d still like to know the answer please.

Many thanks


Mark Avery


Note added later in day:

I am grateful to the PDNP for a copy of this letter which was sent by them to The Times but not published:



Simon Barnes is right to shine a light on the sad and unacceptable level of persecution of birds of prey on some Peak District grouse moors.

However, he misses important facts and is blaming the wrong people.

Simon Barnes appears to associate the Authority with the  illegal actions taking place. Nothing is further from the truth. We wholly condemn illegal persecution of wildlife. Our policies and staff on the ground focus only on supporting land managers who protect wildlife. If we discover any illegal activity we report it to the police.

Moreover, Simon Barnes fails to explain that bird of prey populations have recovered well across much of the national park in recent decades. There is, for example, a good breeding record of goshawk across much of the national park and peregrines have recolonised  successfully important historical sites such as The Roaches.

There is clear evidence of a problem with persecution of hen harrier, goshawk and peregrine associated with some grouse moors. That is where the problem lies. The individuals who own and manage those moors should be accountable and the target of any censure, not the hard working staff of the National Park who labour tirelessly for the conservation of this landscape and its wildlife with good effect.

Cllr Tony Favell MBE

Chairman of the Peak District National Park Authority


Website Pin Facebook Twitter Myspace Friendfeed Technorati Digg Google StumbleUpon Premium Responsive

Get email notifications of new blog posts

Registration confirmation will be emailed to you.

2 Replies to “FoI Friday – 1”

  1. Mark

    Yes, letter is being sent to you. The Times didn't publish it, but we did circulate it to our staff and so it's a reasonably public letter. We deplore persecution and encouraged SB to focus criticism on the people who harm birds of prey not us, because we don't.

    Not aware of any other representations. You'll hear formally from Michelle Sarginson if you've sent the formal FOI through our usual channels - have you?



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.